FTX vs Binance: Binance Subpoenas Kevin O'Leary and Michael Lewis as Witnesses in the $1.76B Clawback Case
Binance has subpoenaed Kevin O'Leary and author Michael Lewis for records in FTX's $1.76B clawback suit. Neither is accused of anything. No ruling yet.
Key numbers
$1.76B
Amount sought
5 (30 Oct and 4 Nov 2026)
Subpoenas noticed
July 2021
Buyout date
None yet
Court ruling on the claim
On Wednesday 4 November 2026, lawyers for Binance filed a short notice in the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. It listed three subpoenas the world's largest crypto exchange had served the week before. One was addressed to Kevin O'Leary, the "Shark Tank" investor who was paid to be the public face of FTX. Five days earlier, a similar notice had listed one addressed to Michael Lewis, the author of "Going Infinite", the 2023 book about FTX's founder, Sam Bankman-Fried.
A subpoena is a court-backed demand for documents or testimony from someone who is not a party to a case, much as a witness can be called to a trial. Neither O'Leary nor Lewis is a defendant. Nothing filed in the case accuses either man of wrongdoing. They have been asked for information in a fight between two other sides.
That fight is over $1.76 billion. The FTX Recovery Trust, which collects money for the customers of the collapsed exchange FTX, and FTX Digital Markets Ltd., its Bahamas arm, are suing Binance and its founder, Changpeng Zhao, known as CZ, to get that sum back. The trust says it is FTX customers' money, paid to Binance in July 2021 to buy back Binance's stake in FTX. Binance and Zhao deny it. No court has ruled on who is right.
Who was subpoenaed
The court docket shows two notices, both filed by three Binance companies: Binance Holdings Limited, Binance Holdings (IE) Limited and Binance (Services) Holdings Limited. Zhao is their co-defendant, and Bloomberg Law, which first reported the subpoenas on 5 November, described them as coming from Binance and Zhao.
The notice of 30 October (docket entry 272) lists subpoenas to Michael Lewis and to Teknos Associates LLC. The notice of 4 November (entry 273) lists subpoenas to Kevin O'Leary, to Steven Ehrlich, a former director of digital assets research at Forbes, and to BDO USA, the accounting and audit firm. Bloomberg Law said Binance and Zhao seek "a host of records and information" from Ehrlich, O'Leary and BDO.
What exactly is being sought from each, and why, has not been made public. The notices themselves do not explain it, and as of 10 November 2026 none of the people or firms named had said anything about the subpoenas in public. Nor had Binance or the FTX Recovery Trust. A subpoena can also be narrowed or challenged in court, and none of these has yet been.
What is public is why reporters linked the two names to this case. O'Leary appeared before the US Senate Banking Committee on 14 December 2022, a month after FTX failed. He told senators the two exchanges had been "at war", and that in his view Binance had put FTX out of business on purpose. He added that he was giving an opinion: "I have an opinion. I don't have the records." He also said Bankman-Fried had told him almost $3 billion of customer money went into buying out Binance's FTX shares. He had been paid about $15 million to promote FTX.
Zhao answered the next day on CNBC's "Squawk Box". "Kevin O'Leary is making a bunch of nonsense claims," he said. "They don't make sense, they don't make any logic." He also called O'Leary a liar.
Lewis spent much of 2022 with Bankman-Fried, before and after the collapse, while writing "Going Infinite". According to Fortune's account of the book, Lewis wrote that Zhao asked $2.2 billion for his stake and, just before signing, asked for another $75 million, which Bankman-Fried paid. Binance declined to comment to Fortune on that account at the time.
There are now three different sizes for the same deal: about $1.76 billion in the trust's lawsuit, $2.2 billion plus $75 million in Lewis's book, and almost $3 billion in what O'Leary said Bankman-Fried told him. They do not match, and the court has not said which, if any, is right.
What the lawsuit says
The story starts in 2019, when Binance and Zhao bought 20% of FTX Trading, the company behind the international exchange FTX.com, for $18.3 million. When Bankman-Fried opened a US business under a parent called West Realm Shires, Binance, Zhao and two Binance executives took an 18.4% stake in it. The complaint says that stake cost two dollars.
On 15 July 2021, FTX bought all of it back. A company is allowed to buy back its own shares from an investor, the way a listed company buys back stock. The trust's complaint says this buyback was different. It alleges that the money really came from Alameda Research, Bankman-Fried's trading firm, and that Alameda was paying with customer deposits taken from FTX. Payment was made in three crypto tokens: FTT, FTX's own token, which works like a store voucher issued by the exchange; BNB, Binance's own token; and BUSD, a stablecoin, which is a digital dollar meant to stay worth exactly $1. To create that BUSD, the complaint says, about $721 million of US dollars from Alameda went to Paxos, the New York trust company that issued it.
The complaint alleges that a balance sheet drawn up just before the deal showed Alameda worth about minus $2.7 billion, with $9.4 billion of debts. It says Caroline Ellison, who ran Alameda, told Bankman-Fried there was not enough money to pay Binance, and that he told her to "borrow" about $1 billion of FTX customer deposits. These are the trust's allegations. Binance and Zhao dispute them, and no court has found them to be true.
Under US bankruptcy law, money paid out by a company that was already broke can be pulled back for its creditors if the company got too little in return or was trying to cheat them. That is called a fraudulent transfer, and getting the money back is a clawback. The trust says FTX was broke in July 2021, sixteen months before the world found out.
Binance and Zhao's answer
Binance has called the claims "legally deficient". In its 2025 motion to dismiss, it said the trust was "pretending that FTX did not collapse as the result of one of the most massive corporate frauds in history", a fraud run by FTX's own leaders. It said FTX "remained a going concern for 16 months" after the buyback, which in its view makes the claim that FTX was already insolvent implausible. It argued that the US court has no power over companies based outside the United States, and that a legal shield for securities deals, section 546(e) of the Bankruptcy Code, bars the claim. Zhao, who lives in the United Arab Emirates, filed his own motion in August 2025. It said he "is not amenable to suit in this forum", that the trust's claims "improperly demand the extension of bankruptcy law abroad", and that the trust "nonsensically" blamed him and others "for Mr. Bankman-Fried's failings".
What the judge has decided so far
On 24 July 2026, Chief Judge Karen B. Owens gave each side part of what it wanted. She dismissed the claims against Samuel Wenjun Lim, Binance's former chief compliance officer, and Dinghua Xiao, another former Binance employee, finding that her court had no jurisdiction over them. She also threw out the four claims that blamed Zhao's tweets of November 2022 for wrecking FTX, the theory closest to O'Leary's Senate testimony. She held that those claims were barred because FTX's own wrongdoing, through Bankman-Fried, is counted against FTX itself, a rule known as in pari delicto (Latin for "in equal fault").
Binance lost the rest. The judge refused to send the case to private arbitration, refused to apply the section 546(e) shield at this early stage, and kept the five fraudulent transfer claims alive against Zhao and four Binance companies. On 30 October 2026 she denied Zhao's request to reconsider, which the Binance companies had joined. The case is now in discovery, the stage where each side can demand documents and testimony from the other and from outsiders. The subpoenas to O'Leary and Lewis are part of that stage. No trial date has been made public.

The aftermath
As of 10 November 2026 none of the five subpoena recipients had said in public whether they will hand over records or challenge the demands, and the scope of each subpoena has not been reported. Binance and Zhao deny the trust's claims. The trust says the $1.76 billion belongs to FTX's customers and creditors. The fraudulent transfer claims against Zhao and four Binance companies continue in Delaware before Chief Judge Karen B. Owens, with no trial date public.
The case sits beside Zhao's own history. In 2023 Binance pleaded guilty in the United States to anti-money-laundering, unlicensed money transmitting and sanctions charges, and Zhao pleaded guilty to failing to keep an effective anti-money-laundering programme. He served four months and was pardoned by President Donald Trump in October 2025. Those criminal cases are separate from this civil claim, and the pardon does not decide it.
What this teaches
- A subpoena is a demand for information, not an accusation. Being asked for records says nothing about the witness's own conduct.
- A clawback suit turns on one question that is hard to prove years later: was the company already broke on the day it paid?
- Public opinions given under oath can travel. O'Leary told senators he had an opinion, not records; four years on, the records are what both sides want.
- The same deal can carry three different prices depending on who tells it. Only a court's finding settles the number.
