CFTC: The US Sues Arkansas and Louisiana, Its 11th and 12th States in the Prediction Market Fight
The CFTC and the Justice Department sued Arkansas and Louisiana to stop state cases against Kalshi and other prediction markets. No court has ruled.
Key numbers
12
States sued by the CFTC
32
Firms in Louisiana's order
23 Nov 2026
Kalshi hearing
None
Final ruling
On Thursday 12 November 2026, the federal government took a state to court for the 11th time this year over the same question: when is a trade really a bet? The United States and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the federal regulator for futures markets, sued the State of Arkansas and its Attorney General, Tim Griffin, in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas. The next day they sued Louisiana in the Eastern District of Louisiana, in New Orleans. Both suits ask federal judges to stop the states from treating prediction markets such as Kalshi as illegal gambling.
The two complaints are close to identical. Each says the federal Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC "exclusive jurisdiction" over these markets, and that state law has to give way. The CFTC counts Arkansas as the 11th state it has sued over the question and Louisiana as the 12th. The Justice Department signed both complaints as co-plaintiff. No judge has ruled on either.
What the two states had done
Arkansas moved first. On 4 November, Griffin sued KalshiEX LLC and Kalshi Inc. in the Circuit Court of Independence County, a state court. The suit, quoted in the federal complaint, says "Kalshi, in large part, is a straightforward gambling platform." It claims thousands of Arkansas residents have traded on Kalshi, "including individuals between the ages of 18 and 20," and that Kalshi "has never paid sales or use taxes" in the state. The claims are made under the Arkansas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, a consumer protection law, along with a claim of unjust enrichment. Arkansas wants an injunction, restitution, civil penalties and unpaid taxes.
"It doesn't take a genius to understand that wagering money on whether the Razorbacks win or lose is gambling," Griffin said when he filed, according to Decrypt. "Arkansas law is concerned with substance, not semantics." He pointed to Kalshi's own self-exclusion tools and deposit limits as signs that the company knows the risks look like gambling.
Louisiana went further. On 12 November, Attorney General Liz Murrill sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase and other platforms in the 21st Judicial District Court for Tangipahoa Parish. That evening Judge Jeffrey Johnson signed a temporary restraining order, granted without hearing the companies, that bars them from offering any "event contract (also known as a wager)" to anyone in Louisiana without a state licence. The federal complaint says the petition targets 32 entities, including federally registered exchanges, brokers for futures (called futures commission merchants) and clearing houses, the firms that settle trades. A hearing on a longer injunction is set for 30 November.
Why federal and state law clash
A prediction market sells contracts on yes-or-no questions: will a team win, will a party take the Senate. A contract pays $1 if the answer is yes and nothing if it is no, and it trades in between at a price that works as the crowd's estimate of the odds. A share trader would call it a simple option. A bookmaker would call it a bet.
That difference decides who is in charge. In the United States, gambling is policed state by state, with state licences, state taxes and state age limits. Futures and other derivatives, contracts whose value depends on something else, are policed nationally by the CFTC, in the way the Securities and Exchange Commission polices the stock market. Kalshi is a "designated contract market", an exchange the CFTC approved in November 2020, so it sits in the federal system.
The federal complaints argue that event contracts are "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act, because the law's definition covers any payment that "is dependent on the occurrence, nonoccurrence, or the extent of the occurrence of an event." Swaps traded on approved exchanges fall under the CFTC's exclusive control. The US Constitution's Supremacy Clause makes federal law "the supreme Law of the Land", so, the government says, a state gambling law cannot reach them. The complaints add history: Congress created the CFTC in 1974 after deciding that "the then-existing patchwork of state-by-state regulation" had damaged national futures markets.
There is also a practical collision. On 5 November the CFTC told exchanges that they "must cease domestic geographic restrictions" within 30 days, meaning they must not block customers by state. Louisiana's order requires the opposite: that the companies geofence the state, blocking users whose location shows Louisiana. Both orders cannot be obeyed at once.
The states answer that a label does not change what a product does. Arkansas says Kalshi skipped the licences, oversight and taxes that legal sportsbooks accept. Louisiana says anyone without a state gaming licence is operating illegally.
What Washington is asking for
Both complaints seek a court declaration that the states' laws are "preempted, unconstitutional, and invalid" as applied to trades on CFTC-regulated exchanges, and preliminary and permanent injunctions stopping state officials from investigating or enforcing those laws against such exchanges and their partners. The Louisiana complaint asks the court, in addition, to stop the state "from enforcing or seeking to extend" Judge Johnson's order. Neither asks for damages.
The Louisiana suit names more than the attorney general. It also names the Louisiana Gaming Control Board, its chair Christopher Hebert and its members, the State Police Gaming Enforcement Division, State Police Superintendent Frank Besson and Revenue Secretary Jarrod Coniglio.
The complaints also put a size on what the states could do. Arkansas's consumer law allows penalties of up to $10,000 per violation. The federal government estimates that if Arkansas counted each trade as a violation, the penalties "could reach the hundreds of millions of dollars", against fees Kalshi says are $0.07 to $2.63 per 100 contracts. Arkansas has not named a figure. In Louisiana, the federal complaint says, a state law change in force since 1 August (Act No. 182) means anyone who "engages in gambling by computer" faces a fine of up to $100,000 and up to five years in prison.
CFTC chairman Michael Selig called Louisiana's case "naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt" in the agency's statement. Of Arkansas, he said the state "seeks to shut down event contracts ranging from sports and politics to other important world events." Speaking at a Cantor conference on 13 November, he said states were "essentially trying to lock up founders and CEOs of these companies," according to The Block. "That's not something that should be at the risk of going to jail," he said.
What the states and Kalshi say
Arkansas disagrees. "We disagree with the CFTC's assertion that federal regulation of prediction markets preempts Arkansas's laws concerning gambling," Jeff LeMaster, a spokesman for Griffin, told Courthouse News by email on 13 November. He said Kalshi had opened its platform to people "as young as 18 years old" and "profited from those wagers."
CMZ found no public reply from Murrill to the federal suit by 14 November. Her most recent statement, made after the state order and before the CFTC sued, was: "It's not complicated: if you aren't a licensed gaming operator, you aren't legal."
Kalshi has its own federal case against Louisiana officials, filed in the Western District of Louisiana in October. On 12 November it asked that court for an emergency restraining order. At a status conference on 13 November, according to the court docket and RG, its lawyers asked to withdraw that request and keep their motion for a preliminary injunction. Judge Edwards will hear it on 23 November. The same day Kalshi told users in Louisiana that "your government says you can't use Kalshi anymore," RG reported. The Block reported no answer from Kalshi to its questions about the Arkansas suit.
The aftermath
The Arkansas case, No. 4:26-cv-01255, was assigned to US District Judge Brian S. Miller. Courthouse News reported no ruling on the government's request for an injunction. The Louisiana case, No. 2:26-cv-02612, had a second filing on 13 November about a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, according to the CourtListener docket, and two motions to intervene the same day. Their text was not public.
The Louisiana state order lasts 10 days from 12 November unless the court extends it, and the state court hearing is on 30 November. In Kalshi's federal case, Louisiana's answer is due on 18 November and Kalshi's reply on 20 November, before the 23 November hearing.
Earlier cases point both ways. The Third Circuit appeals court sided with Kalshi against New Jersey, and federal judges granted the government preliminary injunctions in Arizona, Illinois and Minnesota. In September the Sixth Circuit found that Kalshi had not shown its sports contracts were swaps and let Ohio and Tennessee apply their gambling laws. The government lost in Wisconsin and has appealed. The Fifth Circuit, which covers Louisiana, has not ruled on the question. None of these cases decides whether Kalshi or any other platform broke a state law, and no court has found that any did.
What this teaches
- Whether a prediction market contract is a swap or a bet decides who regulates it, who taxes it and who can prosecute it.
- The federal government is now suing states on the platforms' behalf, which lets it seek orders the companies cannot always win alone.
- A CFTC order to stop blocking customers by state and a state order to block them can both be in force at once, and no company can obey both.
- A restraining order granted without hearing the other side is a pause, not a verdict.
