Court Watch

ZachXBT: He Says Indian Police Froze the Wrong Man's $3M at Gate, Mistaking a Bridge for a Scam

ZachXBT says Andhra Pradesh police froze an innocent Chinese investor's Gate account, then won a court order. Gate says police records show a different path.

ZachXBT: He Says Indian Police Froze the Wrong Man's $3M at Gate, Mistaking a Bridge for a ScamLogo: Gate
Gate is the exchange holding the frozen account; ZachXBT's claims concern the tracing, not the exchange.

Key numbers

  • About $3M

    Account Value When Frozen (ZachXBT)

  • About $1.5M

    Value Now (ZachXBT)

  • $1.7M

    Alleged Scam Victim's Loss

  • None

    Assets Handed Over (Gate)

On 17 November 2026 the blockchain investigator ZachXBT published a long thread saying that police in the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh froze the wrong person's money. He says a Chinese investor lost access to a Gate account worth about $3 million because investigators mistook an ordinary crypto service for a fraud, and that an Indian court has since ordered the account's contents paid to the complainant. Everything below is ZachXBT's account unless stated otherwise. No court has heard his evidence.

The thread challenges a case CMZ has already covered. That earlier report carried the police version only.

What ZachXBT says happened

The case began, according to ZachXBT, with a woman who allegedly lost $1.7 million in bitcoin, tether, dogecoin and solana in May 2025 to a pig butchering scam. Pig butchering is a long con in which a stranger builds trust over weeks, then persuades the victim to pour savings into a fake investment website, the way a farmer fattens a pig before slaughter. The Andhra Pradesh Crime Investigation Department (CID), the state's specialist crime branch, registered it as Crime No. 10/2025 and filed a charge sheet, the document in which police set out their case for a court, in March 2026.

ZachXBT says the investor deposited 15 bitcoin into Gate in July 2025 and the exchange froze his whole account. An exchange freeze means the company stops a customer from withdrawing or trading, much as a broker might lock an account while it asks where the money came from. ZachXBT puts the account at roughly $3 million at the time and about $1.5 million today. He says the Indian order hands all of it to the complainant.

The bridge that police allegedly mislabelled

The core of the dispute is two bitcoin addresses. ZachXBT says they were reported by Indian police as belonging to Alibarbit.bit, one of the two websites named in the CID's own press release as a fraud platform. He says that label was wrong and that both addresses belong to the bridge of Merlin Chain.

A bridge is a service that moves coins between networks, like a currency counter that takes your pounds and hands back euros. Merlin Chain is a separate network built on top of bitcoin. Because a bridge pays thousands of users from the same few addresses, any one of them can look connected to whoever else used it. He says Merlin's addresses are unlabelled in most compliance tools, the software exchanges use to flag dirty money.

He published three withdrawals that he says match three payouts to the investor from those addresses: 10.1368 bitcoin on 25 March 2025, 4.9071 on 6 May and 9.9796 on 17 June, arriving as 10.1367, 4.907 and 9.9795 bitcoin. He says the investor put 50 bitcoin into Merlin on 28 March 2024, over a year before the alleged theft, and that he found no on-chain link to the scam.

He adds two points. The 15 bitcoin in the first deposit came from a wallet funded by the investor's own OKX and Binance withdrawals in January 2023, and sat untouched for years. Police, he notes, froze neither of those accounts.

What Gate and the investor say

Gate answered on X the same day, saying that when the request came in it asked the Indian police for more evidence rather than moving any assets, and that no assets have been handed over. After internal review, it said, the materials police shared trace a different path from the one in his post, though it cannot publish them without authorisation. It is asking police for consent to share more evidence, and says the quickest route is to help its user begin a formal defence through local counsel, since a court has issued an order.

A Gate statement dated 15 November, as reported by Crypto.news, adds a timeline: a police freeze request in September 2025, a request related to a handover in April 2026, and a September 2026 police reply that the case remained under court review.

The investor, who has posted about the case on X, tells a similar story from his side. He says Gate emailed him on 20 July 2025, four days after the deposit, asking for the source of the 15 bitcoin, and that Indian police emailed him in autumn 2025. He says Gate told him on 12 November 2026 that a court had approved moving the funds to the complainant, and estimates about $1.6 million remains. CMZ is not naming him.

Where this differs from CMZ's earlier story

The amounts do not match. The earlier story, based on the CID's statement, put the victim's loss at about $1.5 million, or Rs 15 crore. ZachXBT says $1.7 million. His $1.5 million is a different number: what he says the frozen account is worth now.

The earlier story said the CID traced 15 bitcoin transactions to four Gate accounts and that the court ordered Gate to convert the holdings to USDT, a digital dollar, and send them to the woman. ZachXBT describes one account, the investor's. Whether he is one of the four is not stated by either side. The earlier story said Gate had not commented. It now has.

The earlier story reported that the CID arrested eight accused, two from China. The investor says he may be one of the two Chinese people mentioned in that coverage. CMZ cannot confirm that, and no report read for this article says he was arrested.

What is still unknown

No police statement answering ZachXBT has been found. The court order's text has not been published, and ZachXBT gives no date for it; the earlier story dated the Guntur order 30 October (Crl.M.P. No. 298/2026). CMZ has not checked his blockchain data and links the two stories only by the shared agency, website and exchange.

CMZ's earlier story, "India: A Court Orders Gate to Send Frozen Crypto Back to a $1.5M Scam Victim" (/scam-encyclopedia/tenali-crypto-fraud-gate-court-order/), reported the police account and now carries this challenge.

The aftermath

Gate says it is asking police for consent to share its evidence and is helping the investor contest the order in court. ZachXBT argues exchanges should push back harder on weak cases from some countries. Neither the police nor the complainant had answered publicly in anything read for this article, and the account stays frozen.

What this teaches

  • A bridge pays many strangers from the same addresses, so a link to one is weak evidence of a link to a crime.
  • A freeze can last more than a year before any court tests the tracing.
  • An exchange that obeys a court order cannot argue the user's case for him; the user must do it.
  • Numbers in a dispute need careful reading: a loss, a frozen balance and today's value are three different figures.