Sky: $161M of Savings Cannot Be Withdrawn Because Every Dollar Is Lent Out
Every dollar in Sky's stUSDS pool is lent out, so savers cannot withdraw. A wallet named rune.eth, tied to its founder by analysts, owes $77M.
Key numbers
$161.6M
Deposits that cannot be withdrawn (22 Nov)
$77.2M
Owed by the rune.eth wallet
39.7% a year
Borrow rate (22 Nov)
-25%
SKY price, 13 to 22 Nov
At 02:05 UTC on Sunday 22 November 2026, the stUSDS savings contract on the Ethereum network gave every one of its large holders the same answer to the question of how much they could take out: zero. Inside it sat about $161.6 million of deposits. Almost none of it was there.
stUSDS is a savings product run by Sky, the company formerly known as MakerDAO. Savers hand over digital dollars and earn interest. Those dollars are lent to other people. By Sunday morning, $161.56 million of the $161.57 million in the pool was out on loan, according to the contract's own figures. Savers have been unable to withdraw since about 13 November.
The largest borrower is a wallet registered as rune.eth on the Ethereum Name Service, a naming system that works like web addresses for wallets. On-chain data shows it owes $77.2 million across four loans, 47.8% of everything the pool has lent. An on-chain analyst known as kirbycrypto linked that wallet to Rune Christensen, the co-founder of Sky, TokenPost reported on 18 November. Protos and Crypto Briefing reported the same link. Christensen has not confirmed or denied it in anything published by 22 November.
Nobody is accused of a crime. Borrowing from stUSDS is what the product is for, the loans follow Sky's published rules, and they have no due date. The question is when the money comes back.
What stUSDS is
Sky issues USDS, a stablecoin: a digital dollar meant to stay worth exactly $1, backed by about $10 billion of assets, Christensen says. It also runs sUSDS, a plain savings version that pays a set rate. stUSDS, launched in September 2025, is a separate and riskier product.
Money put into stUSDS is lent to holders of SKY, Sky's own token. SKY works like a voting share in the company: holders vote on Sky's rules and receive part of its income. A SKY holder can lock the tokens up and borrow USDS against them, much as a shareholder can borrow against shares at a broker. stUSDS savers are the lenders. They earn the interest the borrowers pay, minus a small cut for Sky.
If a borrower's SKY falls far enough in value, the system is meant to sell it and repay the savers. That sale is called a liquidation, the crypto version of a margin call that ends with the broker selling the shares.
What 100% lent out means, and why the rate keeps rising
A pool that has lent out every dollar works like a small bank with an empty till. Depositors still own their savings, and on paper they are earning more than ever. But a withdrawal can only be paid when a borrower repays or a new saver puts money in.
That is "100% utilisation". BA Labs, Sky's risk adviser, wrote on the Sky forum on 18 November that the pool's 24-hour average utilisation "has stayed above 99.98% since November 13", and that "stUSDS holders cannot withdraw until borrowers repay or new deposits arrive."
The fix built into stUSDS is price. When more than 90% of the pool is lent, the interest rate climbs automatically, to tempt new savers in and push borrowers to repay. BA Labs logged the borrow rate rising from 13.63% to 16.26% between 12 and 18 November. That was too slow, so it twice raised the speed at which the rate moves on 18 November. Protos put the rate at 25% on 19 November, up from 5% a month earlier. On Sunday the contract showed 39.7% a year for borrowers and savers alike. The ceiling is 50%.
It has not brought much money back. A post cited by Protos said borrowers had repaid "only about $420K of the $162M they owe" in ten days. Crypto Briefing reported that when about 414,000 USDS was repaid on 19 November, a bot redeemed stUSDS in the very next transaction. Small repayments are taken by whoever is fastest.
There is one other exit. A Curve Finance trading pool lets stUSDS holders sell their claims to someone else. Protos reported it holds about $2 million, over 90% of it unwanted stUSDS, and that its price once fell to about 0.3, meaning a seller would have received 30 cents on the dollar.
The rune.eth loans
On-chain data shows the four rune.eth loans are backed by 3.58 billion locked SKY. At Sunday's price of $0.0441 on CoinGecko, that is worth about $157.8 million, roughly twice the $77.2 million debt.
Sky's system does not use that price. For these loans it values SKY at no more than 2.5 cents. At that value the collateral is worth about $89.5 million, about 116% of the debt. The rules say 120% is required. Three of the four rune.eth loans sit below that line, at about 114% each. The fourth is at about 131%.
Both settings came from a forum post on 26 November 2025, during an earlier stUSDS squeeze. It was published under the forum account "rune", which Crypto Briefing attributes to Christensen. It cut the required ratio from 145% to 120% and the SKY price cap to 2.5 cents, so that five small loans near liquidation "are only triggered if SKY falls below 3 cents." It said the ratio "must be increased back to 145%" before the cap could rise. On Sunday the ratio was still 120%.
Liquidations are also switched off. The contract that would sell borrowers' SKY is set to its "stopped" level, so no loan can be forcibly closed, whoever owns it. The rune.eth wallet is not alone: a forum member counted 12 of 39 loans, 44.3% of the loan book, below the required ratio at the capped price. Crypto Briefing reported that the rune.eth loan has had no voluntary repayment since it was opened in May 2025.
What Sky and Christensen say
Christensen wrote on X on 19 November: "A lot of overblown headlines about Sky today." He said: "Sky Protocol is operating normally. USDS remains over collateralized with ~$10B in backing and working as designed." He ended: "I know there are questions about stUSDS. It's a separate, opt-in product, it doesn't back USDS, and USDS and sUSDS holders aren't exposed to it. More on stUSDS soon." By 22 November nothing more on stUSDS had appeared on his X account or the Sky forum. He has not commented publicly on the rune.eth wallet.
Sky's Core Council announced a one-off SKY buyback the same day: 750,000 USDS a day for seven days, 5.25 million USDS in all, "a temporary measure to calm the markets." The SKY bought is burned, removing it for good. Even so, SKY fell from $0.0587 on 13 November to $0.0441 on 22 November on CoinGecko, about 25%.
Opinion is split. Marc Zeller, a former Aave delegate, told Protos there is "nothing wrong", calling stUSDS Christensen's "private credit line to fund his pet projects segregated from the main saving yield." A former MakerDAO delegate known as PaperImperium estimated that even at 50% "it would take several years to be in danger", and that only stUSDS holders could lose money. On the Sky forum, one saver wrote: "the founder who has the biggest loans at the moment should repay something to restore the confidence, even 1-2m payment should help."
A separate report the same week
On 19 November CoinDesk reported a different problem. Inca Digital, a risk analytics firm, traced $518 million of transactions by wallets linked to hackers and sanctioned groups through Sky's Peg Stability Module, the machine that swaps USDC, Circle's digital dollar, for USDS one for one. About $101.9 million was tied to North Korea, including money from the $1.5 billion Bybit hack that the FBI pinned on the Lazarus Group. The worry was that Circle could freeze the wallet holding about $2.7 billion of the module's USDC. CoinDesk then reported that more than $1.5 billion of USDC left the module.
Sky answered that the module has handled over $968 billion and that the flagged activity "would represent roughly 0.03% of that." It said its partner apps block sanctioned users. That report concerns USDS, not stUSDS, and nobody at Sky is accused of anything over it.
The aftermath
As of Sunday 22 November, stUSDS was still lent out to within a few thousand dollars of its $161.6 million total, the largest holders could withdraw nothing, and the rate was 39.7% a year, heading for its 50% ceiling. The rune.eth wallet owed $77.2 million. Liquidations were still switched off and the required collateral ratio was still 120%, a year after the forum post that lowered it said it must return to 145%.
Christensen promised "more on stUSDS soon" on 19 November. Nothing had followed by Sunday. Sky's seven-day SKY buyback runs until about 26 November.
Savers are not owed less than before. On paper their balances grow faster than ever. What they lack is a way out until borrowers repay, new savers arrive, or Sky's governance changes the rules. The other route, selling stUSDS on Curve, has a few million dollars of room at most.
What this teaches
- A savings pool that lends out every dollar can pay a record rate and still pay nobody who wants to leave.
- Read who the borrowers are. When nearly half a lending pool sits with one wallet, the savers depend on that one borrower.
- A collateral rule called temporary can stay in place for a year. Check the current settings, not the promise.
- If liquidations are switched off, a loan backed by a falling token has no automatic brake.
- Rate rises only work if someone has the cash to answer them. They cannot force a borrower to repay.
