The Rap Sheet

Holograph: Five Years in Paris for Printing 1 Billion Tokens Worth $14M on Paper

A Paris court has sentenced Holograph's former technical lead to five years for secretly printing 1 billion extra tokens. He got about $1.3M in cash.

The logo of Holograph, which issued the HLG token.

Key numbers

  • 5 years, part suspended

    Sentence

  • €600,000

    Fine

  • 1B HLG, ~$14M

    Minted (paper value)

  • ~$1.3M

    Cashed out

On the first day of his trial in Paris, the man accused of printing a billion unauthorised crypto tokens told the judges why he had done it. It was, he said, a fit of nerves, meant to hurt the company he had fallen out with. It was not, he insisted, about the money.

On Friday 6 November 2026 the 13th criminal chamber of the Paris court gave its answer. Vitaly K., a Ukrainian developer in his thirties who lived in Paris and is identified by French court reporters only by his first name and initial, was convicted of breaking into a computer system, organised fraud, money laundering and criminal conspiracy. He was sentenced to five years in prison and fined €600,000, which the court justified by the large income he had earned from his work.

Agence France-Presse reported that two of the five years are to be served and the other three are suspended on probation. ZDNET France, which followed the hearings, reported the split the other way round, with two years suspended. Both agree on the five years and the fine, and prosecutors had asked for five years and €800,000.

The crime sounds larger than the proceeds. The tokens were worth about $14 million (€12.5 million) on the day, according to prosecutors. The cash that actually came out was about $1.3 million.

The man who kept the key

Holograph was a project for issuing digital tokens that could move between different blockchains, the separate payment networks on which crypto runs. It was run by the Holograph Foundation, based in the Cayman Islands, and had its own coin, HLG, which traded on crypto exchanges much as a small company's shares trade on a stock market.

Vitaly K. started on the protocol in April 2021 and became its technical lead. The company found him through a website, NFTheft, where an anonymous writer calling himself "Monsieur Personne" (Mister Nobody) exposed security problems with NFTs, digital collectibles that work like certificates of ownership. He told the court on 16 October that he was the man behind it. Reports of the case call him an employee, but Holograph's own account calls him a contractor, and the deal was struck between companies outside France.

It went sour over pay. Holograph says it paid him about $1.5 million and that he then claimed a further $435,000 as a final settlement. In the summer of 2023 the company reported that about €435,000 had been diverted from its crypto wallets. It did not go to the police. In court he explained that he had taken funds until he received what he was owed. His contract ended in October 2023.

His access did not end with it. Holograph's post-mortem, published on 2 July 2024 after an investigation with the security firm Halborn, says a wallet nicknamed 0xC0ffee, which he managed, was still the administrator of an old piece of the system. In the language of a company, the head of IT had been shown the door and had kept the master key to the share register.

Printing a billion extra shares

Minting means creating new tokens. HLG had a ceiling of 10 billion, the equivalent of a company's authorised share count. Printing a billion more off the books is like someone with access to the register issuing himself 10% more shares, then selling them to strangers before anyone notices.

The steps, according to the post-mortem, were patient. Holograph ran on smart contracts, code that moves money by itself according to its rules. In April and May 2024 the administrator wallet was used to plant hidden instructions, called jobs, in the contract that handled transfers between networks. The old link was then removed, and the jobs sat unused for weeks.

At 08:32 UTC on 13 June 2024, one of them was fired on Mantle, one of the networks Holograph used, disguised as an ordinary transfer. At 09:20 UTC a billion HLG were sent across to Ethereum, the largest network of this kind. The first attempt to complete that transfer failed. Eight minutes later a function built to retry failed transfers did the job, and the billion tokens existed.

They went to accounts on five exchanges, the crypto equivalent of brokers: Bybit, Gate, KuCoin, Bitget and Backpack. Selling began immediately, and HLG fell almost 80% in nine hours, from $0.014 to $0.0029. Extra shares dumped on a thin market destroy their own value, which is why $14 million on paper never existed as $14 million in anyone's pocket.

Court reporting says about 200 million tokens were sold before the accounts were frozen and that the rest were frozen or seized, while the post-mortem says about 200 million were frozen on the exchanges. Both put the proceeds at about $1.3 million, taken out as USDT, a digital dollar issued by Tether. The post-mortem says that money was then turned into ether and scattered through other wallets and mixers, services that blend coins to hide their origin.

An NFT gave him away

Holograph filed a complaint in France that same month and already had a name for the police. France's anti-cybercrime office led the inquiry with the BRI, an elite French police unit against organised crime, Europol, Italy's anti-mafia directorate and the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service. Four people were arrested in Italy in August 2024, and two of them were pursued in France. Vitaly K. was handed to France and jailed in September.

The evidence, as ZDNET France described it at trial, was unglamorous. Exchange accounts had been opened before the mint. One wallet was first funded by another account linked to him through an NFT he had created himself. Another, which received 600 million HLG, had been opened by a friend from a Paris café, who told police he did it at Vitaly K.'s request and cited an expired passport. Conversations recovered by police suggested the aim was to send HLG to zero.

The defence did not dispute who pressed the button. Its argument, from the lawyer Robin Binsard, was that the weakness already existed and that Holograph knew about it. No code had been altered, he said, so his client had merely walked through a wide open door, which was neither fraud nor a break-in. Holograph, represented by the firm Hashtag Avocats, accepted that no source code was rewritten at the moment of the attack. Its case was that he had kept access he had no right to and had misused an administrator function already in the contracts. The court convicted.

The other two, and the price of a crash

The two others, who appeared at liberty and were accused of helping spread the funds across exchange accounts from Paris and Roquebrune-Cap-Martin on the French Riviera, were also convicted. One man received two years, 14 months of them suspended, and an €80,000 fine. A woman received a two-year suspended sentence and a €40,000 fine. Prosecutors had sought two years and €100,000 each.

All three must jointly pay the foundation just over €1.2 million, which covers the dollars taken and other harm. The foundation wanted more. It asked the court to hold them liable for the collapse of HLG's market price and to order a new hearing with a financial expert. The judges refused, finding that the harm was not certain because the coin was very new and its price had already been falling. It had peaked at about $0.028 on 24 May 2024, according to CoinGecko, and had halved by the morning of the mint.

Binsard called the price claim a fantasy and the ruling satisfactory, and said it should allow his client to be free in the coming months. Vitaly K. has been in custody for more than two years.

No appeal had been reported by 9 November. One is still possible: article 498 of the French code of criminal procedure gives the parties ten days from the judgment, which runs to 16 November. The convictions are not final while that window is open.

Bar chart: $14 million paper value against $1.3 million cashed outChart: CMZ
What the printed tokens were worth on paper, and what came out.

The aftermath

Holograph survived the mint only in name. Its lawyer told the court that the company had come to a complete standstill and was preparing to liquidate so it could repay creditors, because clients had lost faith in the project. The foundation's plan in 2024 had been to destroy tokens to bring the supply back to the 10 billion ceiling, restart its transfers and rebuild. It said the frozen tokens would be recovered through law enforcement.

HLG never came back. It was at about $0.001 by the end of December 2024, according to the financial platform Finary. CoinGecko's last recorded data, from June 2026, put it at about $0.000002, with every token in circulation worth about $3,200 in total and no trading volume at all.

The court's refusal on the price leaves ordinary HLG holders where they were. The money ordered in this case goes to the foundation, and no report describes any payment to people who bought the coin and watched it fall. Those who bought before the mint had already seen it halve. Whether the foundation ever collects the €1.2 million, from three defendants with fines of their own to pay, is a separate question.

French courts have a mixed record on this kind of case. Agence France-Presse recalled that in 2023 a young man was acquitted over the hack of Platypus, an American platform, with an alleged loss of $9.5 million. This time, the verdict went the other way.

What this teaches

  • When someone leaves, every key they held has to be changed, including the ones on old systems nobody uses any more.
  • An earlier theft that goes unreported to police is a warning, and the person who committed it should not keep any access.
  • The value of printed tokens is a paper figure. About $14M was minted and about $1.3M was cashed out, because selling extra tokens crushes their price.
  • Exchanges can freeze accounts quickly when alerted, which is why most of the billion tokens never turned into money.
  • A court needs proof that a crime caused a price fall. A coin that was already sinking makes that very hard to show.