The Rap Sheet

Peraire-Bueno Brothers: Judge Acquits Them of Fraud Over $25M Taken From Ethereum Trading Bots

A Manhattan judge cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of every charge over $25M taken from trading bots in 2023: prosecutors never proved a lie.

Peraire-Bueno Brothers: Judge Acquits Them of Fraud Over $25M Taken From Ethereum Trading BotsSeal: US District Court SDNY; logo: Ethereum
The case was heard in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Key numbers

  • $25M

    Taken from bots (2023)

  • 12 seconds

    Time it took

  • 0

    Charges left

  • Acquitted

    Verdict

On 16 November 2026, two and a half years after they were charged, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno walked out of the first criminal case over MEV with nothing against them. US District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke of the Southern District of New York granted their motion for a judgment of acquittal on every remaining charge: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Her 46-page opinion and order directs the court clerk to close the case.

The brothers, who studied at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, were accused of taking about $25 million from automated trading bots on Ethereum in April 2023. Their first trial, which ran for nearly four weeks, ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury deliberated for three days and could not agree. Prosecutors asked for a retrial. Under the judge's order, there will not be one.

"The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes," Clarke wrote. "Because the Government failed to prove that the Peraire-Buenos made any material misrepresentations in the execution of their scheme, the motion is granted, and a judgment of acquittal is entered."

What the brothers did, according to the evidence

Ethereum is a blockchain, a shared public ledger that adds a new page, called a block, every twelve seconds. The computer chosen to publish each page is a validator. Before trades reach that page they sit in a public waiting room, where anyone can read them.

MEV, short for maximal extractable value, is the extra money that can be made from choosing the order of those waiting trades. It is a little like a broker who sees the client orders before they hit the market. The most common form is the sandwich: a bot spots a large buy order, buys the same token just ahead of it, then sells straight after, so the trader in the middle pays more and the bot pockets the gap. Sandwich bots take tens of millions of dollars a year from Ethereum traders this way.

The Peraire-Buenos targeted the sandwich bots themselves. According to the ruling, they spent months testing a plan they called "Omakase", set up and registered sixteen validators, and waited until one of them was picked to publish a block. On 2 April 2023, New York time, they sent eight "lure transactions" into the waiting room, shaped to look like easy prey. The bots took the bait and committed millions of dollars of tokens to sandwich them.

The trick lay in a piece of software called MEV-Boost, made by the company Flashbots. It passes blocks to validators through a middleman, the relay, which keeps the contents hidden until the validator signs a commitment to publish. The brothers' validator signed a deliberately invalid block, which the court says the Ultrasound Relay did not check. That revealed the bots' private trades. The brothers then built a second block that swapped their lures for "dump transactions", selling the very tokens the bots had just bought. The bots lost about $25 million in twelve seconds.

Afterwards, the ruling says, the brothers moved the money through hundreds of transactions, one wallet holding $3 million was frozen, and by October 2023 they had turned the rest into cash. Flashbots briefly blacklisted their validator.

Why the judge said it was not wire fraud

Wire fraud in the United States needs a lie: a false statement, or a false impression, important enough to change what the victim does. Being sneaky is not enough. Prosecutors offered a long list of candidates, including posing as an honest validator, the bait trades and the invalid signature. Clarke rejected each one.

The lure transactions, she found, were real trades. They were executed and added to the blockchain a minute later, not cancelled. Prosecutors had compared them to spoofing, the banned practice of placing fake orders on a stock or futures exchange to trick other traders. Clarke said that comparison fails on Ethereum because "the lure transactions in Omakase were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct." Ethereum, the opinion notes, has no terms of use.

The invalid signature did not fool anyone either, because the relay never looked at the parts the brothers had faked. And the government's fallback, that the scheme as a whole was deceptive, did not work: "the Government is asking the Court to find evidence of a material misrepresentation without identifying one." Evidence that the brothers hid their plans and their identities showed intent, Clarke wrote, but intent cannot stand in for a lie. With no wire fraud, the money laundering charge fell too, since it needed fraud proceeds to launder.

In a footnote, the judge went further. She declined to rule on whether the charges breached the brothers' due process rights, their constitutional right to a fair process, but said "this prosecution raises serious due process concerns."

The reaction

The brothers' lawyers had no immediate comment, and a spokesperson for the Manhattan US Attorney's office declined to comment, Reuters reported. Bloomberg reported that the ruling means the brothers avoid a retrial. Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of the crypto policy group Coin Center, called the case a "massive overstep", according to The Block.

Prosecutors had argued at a hearing in March 2026 that the case "has always been about deception, tricks, misrepresentations on the blockchain," Assistant US Attorney Danielle Kudla said, as reported by DL News. Clarke's conclusion borrowed words from an appeal court: the case was never about whether the conduct "was improper, objectionable, or even despicable." It was only about whether it was wire fraud. A jury could not decide that. A judge has now decided it was not.

The aftermath

The court has ordered the case closed. No charge remains: the fourth count in the superseding indictment, conspiracy to receive stolen property, was dropped earlier after the government said it would not pursue it, and the judge's order acquits the brothers of the other three. As of 17 November 2026, the US Attorney's office had declined to comment and no report had said whether prosecutors will try to challenge the ruling.

The ruling does not say what the brothers did was right; Clarke said that was not the question. It says the wire fraud law, as charged, did not fit. For Ethereum's sandwich bots, which still take money from ordinary traders every day, the ruling is a reminder that a market with no rulebook protects no one by rule, including the bots.

What this teaches

  • An acquittal is a legal finding, not a moral one. The judge said plainly that she was not deciding whether the conduct was right.
  • Wire fraud needs a lie that matters. Hiding a plan, or being clever with code, is not the same thing in law.
  • Ethereum has no rulebook like a stock exchange. That cuts both ways: bots that profit from other traders' orders had no rule protecting them either.
  • Software flaws are found by users. The relay did not check the fields the brothers faked, and Flashbots' design depended on everyone playing fair.